Taro Logo

Beware the performance review

Full Stack Developer
Current Employee
Has worked at BNY for 20 years
October 23, 2025
Boston, Massachusetts
2.0
Doesn't RecommendNegative OutlookNo CEO Opinion
Pros

Flexible working hours - at a minimum WFH on Fridays. Good benefits.

Cons

Forced ranking mandates 10% will get no bonus and 15% will be rated 'partial met expectations' and get low merit / bonus.

25% is way too high unless you have a real issue with your hiring and perpetually hire sub-par employees.

Performance rating is a joke - managers are forced to think about who they would like to keep.

Career progress is extremely hard as promotions are tied to the highest performance rating that is highly restricted to a percentage.

However, play increases are also tied to ratings so managers are forced to use rating to adjust pay that has drifted way out of line in order to keep employees rather than focus on career progression.

It's deeply flawed.

Long hours.

Advice to Management

This isn't the oughts. Effectively firing 10% of employees might have worked in prior decades or in a different industry. This is not helping. We are not a 'high performance organization' with the 'best of the best' applying to work here. You don't pay those salaries (except perhaps to exec level positions).

We need to retain seasoned employees as the systems are old and complex. What you are doing is slow corporate suicide on the advice of consultants.

Additional Ratings

Work/Life Balance
1.0
Culture and Values
4.0
Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion
5.0
Career Opportunities
1.0
Compensation and Benefits
3.0
Senior Management
2.0

Was this helpful?

BNY Interview Experiences