Instacart

Good Benefits, Good People, Good Future.

Toxic Culture, Back-Stabbing & Empty Promises

I volunteered for a “nice-to-have” project with no hard deadline and kept my senior manager in the loop every week, discussing progress, blockers, and next steps in our one-on-one meetings. He’d always say, “I’m here to support you,” but in reality, he never offered any tangible help. I was left troubleshooting alone, on an island.

Then, in larger meetings with critical stakeholders, he’d feign surprise about our agreed plan and suddenly demand, “Why isn’t this done yet? Are there any blockers? Did you need my help? It's been a week since we've talked about it." He’d treat the project as my personal failure, inventing “issues” we’d already resolved and using the moment to elevate himself. This happened almost every week, eroding my credibility and morale.

This guy even suggested that I take a severance package and leave the company.

Key Issues:

• Back-Stabbing Dynamics: Publicly blaming me for “missed” deadlines he’d already acknowledged in private.
• Empty Promises of Support: Claimed to help but provided no guidance or resources—left me isolated.
• False Narratives: Framed routine progress discussions as my incompetence.
• No Escalation Path: Reporting to his skip-level did nothing—and I was ultimately laid off for “performance.”

Recommendations:

Private, Constructive Feedback Only: Move all critiques into one-on-one sessions and follow up with clear, actionable support.

Deliver on Support Promises: If a manager offers help, they must provide resources, guidance, or stakeholder alignment—don’t just pay lip service.

Blame-Free Post-Mortems: After any delay or setback, focus on “what broke in our process?” rather than “who dropped the ball?”

Manager Accountability: Tie leaders’ performance reviews to team engagement, project success rates, and retention metrics.

Leadership Training: Equip managers with coaching and empathy skills so they uplift their teams instead of tearing them down.