Taro Logo

Engineering Manager Interview Experience - Italy

September 1, 2026
Negative ExperienceNo Offer

Process

First applied and completed a full 5-stage interview loop in 2023 (Recruiter, Management, Code Review, System Design, Values/Culture) with positive overall feedback, but in the end they decided to extend the offer to another candidate.

Was contacted by their recruiter in 2025 for another open position, my request for fast-tracking based on past performance resulted in dropped communications.

Re-engaged recently via outbound recruiter outreach and was put through the full technical process again (Recruiter, Management, Code Review, System Design) with a rejection mid-process after the technical rounds with feedback contradicting previous evaluations.

Key takeaways & observations:

  1. Despite having completed the full technical loop previously, I was required to redo the exact same battery of interviews upon recruiter outreach. Surprisingly, the technical exercises, both the Code Review and System Design prompt, were 100% identical to the ones used years prior.

  2. Completing identical challenges yielded opposite, contradictory feedback across the two hiring cycles. The Code Review exercise lacked clear framing or active steering from the interviewer, yet starting the exercise from high-level architectural and best practices observations was penalized in the final evaluation in favor of delving straight into granular bug hunting, a criteria that varies heavily by individual interviewer rather than a standardized rubric.

  3. In the System Design round, presenting clear trade-offs between monolithic and microservice approaches before choosing the latter for a system expected to scale beyond MVP was dismissed as "unnecessary early complexity." The feedback felt rigid and disconnected from standard engineering manager responsibilities, where evaluating architectural trade-offs is expected.

Advice to management:

▪ Standardize interviewer calibration: Train technical interviewers to provide active signposting and use objective, calibrated rubrics rather than penalizing candidates for unstated preferences in vague prompts.

▪ Improve ATS tracking & candidate experience: Respect candidates' time when conducting outbound sourcing. If re-engaging past candidates, leverage past interview data or streamline duplicate technical exercises rather than assigning identical tests twice.

Questions

There is a first manager interview covering past management role experiences, in terms of helping people grow, managing underperformers, managing stakeholders, etc.

There is a code review round where the candidate is requested to review an already implemented API controller looking for issues.

There is a system design round where the candidate is asked to design a digital wallet.

Was this helpful?

Interview Statistics

The following metrics were computed from 2 interview experiences for the Mollie Engineering Manager role in Italy.

Success Rate

0%
Pass Rate

Mollie's interview process for their Engineering Manager roles in Italy is extremely selective, failing the vast majority of engineers.

Experience Rating

Positive0%
Neutral50%
Negative50%

Candidates reported having very negative feelings for Mollie's Engineering Manager interview process in Italy.

Mollie Work Experiences