Taro Logo

Seems great, but favoritism, lying, negligence, and unlawful conduct aren't uncommon

Localization QA Tester
Former Employee
Worked at Square Enix for 2 years
September 5, 2022
El Segundo, California
1.0
Doesn't Recommend
Pros

Pros are that this is a AAA game company and it will look good on your resume. It's also probably one of the easiest QA jobs you'll find to get your foot in the door. In the words of management, you're "basically a glorified proofreader."They don't do crunch like a lot of companies still do, although they do have OT at times.

While my interactions are very limited, I do far have good impressions of the head of their HR. She was the only person at Square Enix NA who tried to hear me out and understand my experiences there. Unfortunately, it mattered little in the long run because I was nothing more than a temp with clearly little value there. HR can and will only do so much for a lower employee, and HR at he staffing agency even less. In the end, the company still sides with upper management and will believe them over anyone else.

Cons

First of all, if you're looking to advance in the company through a contractor position in support or QA, good luck. It's not even that full-time positions rarely open up, it's that unless you're close friends with the right people in the company, it's not going to matter if you do your job well or you get along with your peers, either be a complete standout or you'll be led to believe you have a chance when the company already made its mind up about you and you're going to see that person who hired in 3 months ago pass you up completely. They had contractors on as permatemps for years, then gave very little notice when they were forced to change policies.

Which leads me to the fact that there is a complete lack of transparency. They will always avoid confrontation and tell you you're doing well or there's nothing wrong, so when you're treated as if you're the worst person on the planet, you're left feeling like a complete failure, wondering what you did wrong. Leadership and management hate confrontation in general, and if you're a contractor, they'll just avoid it altogether until you're gone and you're not their problem anymore. They do not care about your growth or well-being or how you feel. Why do I say this? Well, because of how they handled situations over the years.

They've gaslit people and told them their concerns were untrue, when in reality, they were doing the exact things people believed them to be doing. For example, retaliating after a harassment complaint:

"You make it sound like that entire place conspired against you, and that's simply not true."

Yet the reality which I found out from FT employees was this:

"Literally the only thing I knew about you was that you were walking trouble. [Several leads and managers] all gave impressions that you were more trouble than your worth as a tester. I remember choosing testers at one point for a project and people pointed out that you may not be the best worker because of random personal stuff. Like, the attitude would shift. Dramatically. I would mention your name and ask how you were as a tester and they would bring up the one time you had been caught not doing work... But then people wouldn't fire you so I was confused. It seemed like one incident painted everyone's opinion of you. But that one incident didn't make sense to make EVERYONE has such an opinion. I was so confused by how it seemed like all of management was against you.

I remember working with you on [project] and everything being fine. Like nothing was anything of a deal. You were chatty and worked hard, but in the background I still remember [leadership/management] trying their damnedest to get you fired."

While the offenders had their reputations and jobs protected:

"One of the things I hate the most about these posts is seeing the truth behind each situation, instead of the misdirection, half-truths, or outright lies either told to leadership and passed on, or by leadership to presumably cover up severity.

…it was "Oh, he's leaving because he got another job.", not because he was incapable of separating personal feelings from work, and put himself into a compromising situation of "awkwardness" because he couldn't get the over it and unfairly blamed you.

…it was "He's going through some personal issues and will no longer be working here." and not the horrifying reality of him stalking a current employee because once again, he couldn't get over his personal feelings.

…it was "Oh yeah, our relationship is going pretty well so far." while he was clearly trying his hardest to use his position to pursue other people. Absolutely vile."

And they were given chance after chance while victims were never once spoken to by management:

"I talked it over with management and I'm returning on the 19th. I hope you're okay with us working at the same place together."

They knew about inappropriate behavior committed by employees and turned a blind eye for years. And when asked, they defended their actions and claimed it's just how things work there:

"I saw them both come back in the room about 15 minutes later. Separately, but he was right behind her. I've also seen him get up and leave a few minutes after her, as if trying to catch her in the hallway. I drove around when I left to see if something was happening but didn't see anything. But this is insane."

"I ran into him in the restroom the day after you made that kind gesture, and for whatever reason, he decided to make an incredibly vulgar and lewd comment to me…about you. … I reported him to the proper people because his comment was disrespectful and inappropriate, but part of what made last week worse [...] was that I got word that nothing could be done at the moment."

"And on that note, was the sex question one that you weren't comfortable with and I went too far?"

It doesn't matter if these types of things are ever fixed. They make excuses for inaction and failing their employees, and use the excuse of the toxic environment as an excuse to remove people they couldn't otherwise fire:

"If I reached out to make a case for you about everything that happened with him, everything I knew before and found out since, how you felt, what happened the day you interviewed, and made my own case about your attendance if someone brought it up, and then you never actually contacted [them] to go back anyway, that diminishes me along with anyone else that would have stood up for you."

"I had pushed you to be away from there because of [redacted] from the beginning. With no other context at the time of what you wanted."

"And even if I had encouraged you to report it I'm pretty confident you wouldn't have listened to me. And I'm glad you did on your own."

If you notice you're not getting called back despite being told you're in the talent pool, they'd love to work with you again, you're doing a good job? It's because they're lies. I heard repeatedly that I was being considered, that I was at the top of a list, and then nothing. Then another project would be coming up, and nothing. I was told to apply for an internal position that would be "open to [me] without reservation. That it was the only way I'd ever get an honest discussion with them. And in the end, I heard nothing and then was automatically rejected. The thing is that if you finally have enough, they can say they "offered" you opportunities. But they never existed.

In fact, I was told I couldn't even ask for feedback regarding my treatment at the company and if I asked, I could never work there again. This exchange was just in 2021, with the company backtracking and making claims about my character and work history in 2022 after various individuals told me I didn't anything wrong and I didn't deserve the treatment they gave me.

And to show even more just how two-faced this company can be, I was repeatedly told, "Also please keep in mind that you can look while you're on project. You can always give some notice, or none, and bounce and it shouldn't count against you," when I was being taken out of the talent pool and not being given work. Then one day after not hearing back for over a year, I was told I was unreliable and did exactly what they said I could — even after being assured I was still in good standing: "Totally get it. You are still in Square Enix's talent pool."

Don't think this company is beyond inappropriate comments and behavior either, because they're absolutely not. For example, these are higher ups to a direct report/contractor:

"Thank you for putting up with my stuff. You are literally one of the prettiest girls I have ever known... Top 5!!"

"I think I was just thinking that I'd never really properly apologized, as it took me a while to to admit that the reason I was so sensitive about everything was that I was totally into you at the time."

"After I got it, I periodically started thinking that you were someone I wanted to get to know better. Of course, with everything that happened, I didn’t want to intrude or complicate things for you, but it’s something I continued to think about. Eventually, after enough time passed where it seemed like you had recalibrated your life, I wanted to try to have a casual conversation with you and see where it might lead to."

There is a no-fraternization policy for the company that seems to be often overlooked for employees who try to make themselves out to be model employees, and especially those in leadership positions. Don't buy it. They have never enforced that policy, and when it was known that leadership continued trying to have relationships with direct reports, guess who would get punished.

In maybe two years of working there, I dealt with harassment, retaliation, and unwanted advances from several employees including people above me, and none of those incidents would have ever been addressed had I not called them out to the entire department. I was repeatedly told I wasn't at fault for what happened or I did nothing wrong, yet they were apparently set on firing me and barring me from returning. Yet when I stood up for myself, it seems that the department reported me as if I was the offender. The people who turned a blind eye to the sexual harassment, took part in violations of company policy, or retaliated against me and ruined my reputation without speaking to me once, got hired or promoted or were given leniency.

The ultimate solution in their eyes was to ignore me until I went away or accuse me of violations I didn't commit when I was told my actions were okay. I even reached out to my leadership to discuss potential issues and have meetings - ones which management never responded to or attended. Management claims I never wanted to speak to them, yet how does that make sense even I repeatedly asked for feedback and a discussion multiple times? How can they claim I was the unreliable one when I only did what they gave me permission to do and I always reached out while they refused to respond?

And pretty much all the people who were involved in sweeping these kinds of things under the rug are current employees. This isn't new either, as several people who approached me after claimed similar things and were willing to vouch for these experiences, some even having gone through filing complaints with the state.

If you're a contractor, don't ever take what this company says at face value. If it weren't for the egregious violations of policies and employment laws, it wouldn't be worth mentioning experiences or writing a review. But I wish I had known of all the things this company swept under the rug for over a decade. I wouldn't have wasted so much time trying to have an honest conversation with them had I known the people there didn't have an honest bone in their body.

If they actually cared, they could've had a discussion or cleared up misunderstandings, when I said it was all I wanted but they haven't once offered any explanation or direct response to any of these grievances. It's always a third party or lawyers trying to just be rid of the contractors.

If you're perfectly fine with a company that will put an employee's reactions to dealing with harassment and leadership who abuse power under more scrutiny than the management and leadership that put them into that situation and refused to help or resolve things, then by all means, this is the place for you!

Honestly, I wanted to be there as long as I could because I liked what I did. But when others have power over your job and decide their personal feelings and opinions of you can dictate the actions they take, then it's not your call. And for the record, I told people who harassed me to stop multiple times. I let people know how I felt about management's treatment. I have the exchanges documented with evidence. But it didn't matter at a company that doesn't let you speak for yourself and then comes up with all sorts of excuses and deflection to save themselves.

Advice to Management

Real leaders don't act like cowards and don't act with only their best interests in mind.

If you can't have honest discussions with your employees or do what's ethically and morally right, if you can't take accountability for your actions and decisions, if you can't stand up for and support all your employees and not only the ones who are your close friends, you shouldn't be in leadership.

Additional Ratings

Work/Life Balance
4.0
Culture and Values
1.0
Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion
2.0
Career Opportunities
1.0
Compensation and Benefits
1.0
Senior Management
1.0

Was this helpful?

Square Enix Interview Experiences