Taro Logo

Check if an Original String Exists Given Two Encoded Strings

Hard
Asked by:
Profile picture
36 views
Topics:
StringsDynamic Programming

An original string, consisting of lowercase English letters, can be encoded by the following steps:

  • Arbitrarily split it into a sequence of some number of non-empty substrings.
  • Arbitrarily choose some elements (possibly none) of the sequence, and replace each with its length (as a numeric string).
  • Concatenate the sequence as the encoded string.

For example, one way to encode an original string "abcdefghijklmnop" might be:

  • Split it as a sequence: ["ab", "cdefghijklmn", "o", "p"].
  • Choose the second and third elements to be replaced by their lengths, respectively. The sequence becomes ["ab", "12", "1", "p"].
  • Concatenate the elements of the sequence to get the encoded string: "ab121p".

Given two encoded strings s1 and s2, consisting of lowercase English letters and digits 1-9 (inclusive), return true if there exists an original string that could be encoded as both s1 and s2. Otherwise, return false.

Note: The test cases are generated such that the number of consecutive digits in s1 and s2 does not exceed 3.

Example 1:

Input: s1 = "internationalization", s2 = "i18n"
Output: true
Explanation: It is possible that "internationalization" was the original string.
- "internationalization" 
  -> Split:       ["internationalization"]
  -> Do not replace any element
  -> Concatenate:  "internationalization", which is s1.
- "internationalization"
  -> Split:       ["i", "nternationalizatio", "n"]
  -> Replace:     ["i", "18",                 "n"]
  -> Concatenate:  "i18n", which is s2

Example 2:

Input: s1 = "l123e", s2 = "44"
Output: true
Explanation: It is possible that "leetcode" was the original string.
- "leetcode" 
  -> Split:      ["l", "e", "et", "cod", "e"]
  -> Replace:    ["l", "1", "2",  "3",   "e"]
  -> Concatenate: "l123e", which is s1.
- "leetcode" 
  -> Split:      ["leet", "code"]
  -> Replace:    ["4",    "4"]
  -> Concatenate: "44", which is s2.

Example 3:

Input: s1 = "a5b", s2 = "c5b"
Output: false
Explanation: It is impossible.
- The original string encoded as s1 must start with the letter 'a'.
- The original string encoded as s2 must start with the letter 'c'.

Constraints:

  • 1 <= s1.length, s2.length <= 40
  • s1 and s2 consist of digits 1-9 (inclusive), and lowercase English letters only.
  • The number of consecutive digits in s1 and s2 does not exceed 3.

Solution


Clarifying Questions

When you get asked this question in a real-life environment, it will often be ambiguous (especially at FAANG). Make sure to ask these questions in that case:

  1. What characters can appear in the original string before encoding (e.g., only lowercase English letters, or other characters as well)?
  2. Can the numeric values in the encoded strings represent zero (e.g., could 'a10b' represent 'ajjjjjjjjjb')?
  3. If it's impossible to derive the original string from both encoded strings, what should I return (e.g., null, false, throw an exception)?
  4. Are the two encoded strings guaranteed to be valid encodings of *some* string, or could they contain errors that would make them un-decodable?
  5. What are the maximum lengths of the encoded strings? I'm thinking about the potential for exponential runtime with the decoding combinations.

Brute Force Solution

Approach

The brute force approach is like trying to decode a secret message by trying every possible combination of letters. We painstakingly check if any possible original string can produce both encoded strings we were given.

Here's how the algorithm would work step-by-step:

  1. Consider all possible original strings, starting from the shortest to longer ones, up to a reasonable length.
  2. For each possible original string, encode it using the first encoding method and check if it matches the first given encoded string.
  3. If the encoded string matches the first encoded string, encode the same original string using the second encoding method.
  4. Check if this second encoded string matches the second given encoded string.
  5. If both encoded strings match the given encoded strings, then we have found a valid original string, and we can stop.
  6. If we have tried all possible original strings up to our pre-defined reasonable length and haven't found a match, then no original string exists.

Code Implementation

def check_original_string_exists_brute_force(
    encoded_string_one,
    encoded_string_two
):
    maximum_original_string_length = 5

    for original_string_length in range(
        1, maximum_original_string_length + 1
    ):
        for i in range(26 ** original_string_length):
            original_string = ""
            temp_i = i

            for _ in range(original_string_length):
                original_string = (
                    chr(ord('a') + temp_i % 26) + original_string
                )
                temp_i //= 26

            encoded_string_one_candidate = encode_string(
                original_string, 1
            )

            # If the first encoded string matches, proceed to check the second.
            if (
                encoded_string_one_candidate
                == encoded_string_one
            ):
                encoded_string_two_candidate = encode_string(
                    original_string, 2
                )

                # If both encoded strings match, we found an original string.
                if (
                    encoded_string_two_candidate
                    == encoded_string_two
                ):
                    return True

    # No matching original string was found within the specified length.
    return False

def encode_string(original_string, encoding_type):
    encoded_string = ""
    for char in original_string:
        if encoding_type == 1:
            encoded_string += str(ord(char))
        else:
            encoded_string += char.upper()
    return encoded_string

Big(O) Analysis

Time Complexity
O(exponential) – The brute force approach involves generating and testing all possible original strings up to a certain length. Let 'k' be the maximum length of original strings considered, and assume each character can be one of 'c' possible characters. The number of possible original strings is then approximately c^1 + c^2 + ... + c^k, which is an exponential function of k. For each of these strings, we need to encode it twice (once for each encoding method) which takes O(k) time for each encoding. The overall time complexity is therefore O( (c^1 + c^2 + ... + c^k) * k), and since the exponential term dominates, the overall complexity is exponential. Therefore, the Big O time complexity is O(exponential).
Space Complexity
O(1) – The brute force approach, as described, explores possible original strings without storing a large number of them simultaneously. It generates and tests strings one at a time. The dominant space usage would stem from the variables needed to store the current original string being tested, encoded strings for comparison, and any index variables used during the encoding process. Since these variables occupy a constant amount of space, regardless of the input string sizes (encoded strings), the overall space complexity is O(1).

Optimal Solution

Approach

The problem involves checking if a potential original string matches two compressed versions of it. We use a process like reverse engineering, attempting to build the original string using the encoded strings as blueprints while checking for inconsistencies to determine if a match is possible.

Here's how the algorithm would work step-by-step:

  1. Start by considering the beginning of both encoded strings.
  2. Use the first encoded string to explore potential ways the original string could start, character by character or number by number (representing repeating characters).
  3. Simultaneously, explore the possibilities offered by the second encoded string in the same manner.
  4. Whenever both encoded strings suggest a potential character to be added to the original, ensure that those characters are the same. If not, the original string cannot exist.
  5. If one encoded string has a number indicating a repeated character, verify that the other encoded string's corresponding segment matches that repetition. If they don't match, the original string cannot exist.
  6. Continue this process, stepping through both encoded strings and building a potential original string, constantly checking for conflicts between the two encoded versions.
  7. If you reach the end of both encoded strings without any conflicts, then a matching original string exists. If you find an irreconcilable conflict at any point, then a matching original string does not exist.

Code Implementation

def check_if_original_string_exists(
    first_encoded_string, second_encoded_string
):
    first_string_length = len(first_encoded_string)
    second_string_length = len(second_encoded_string)

    # Use dynamic programming for memoization
    memo = {}

    def can_form_original_string(
        first_string_index, second_string_index, current_string
    ):
        if (
            first_string_index, second_string_index
        ) in memo:  
            return memo[(first_string_index, second_string_index)]

        if (
            first_string_index == first_string_length
            and second_string_index == second_string_length
        ):
            memo[(first_string_index, second_string_index)] = True
            return True

        if (
            first_string_index == first_string_length
            or second_string_index == second_string_length
        ):
            memo[(first_string_index, second_string_index)] = False
            return False

        # Try decoding from the first encoded string.
        if first_encoded_string[first_string_index].isdigit():
            number_end_index = first_string_index
            while (
                number_end_index < first_string_length
                and first_encoded_string[number_end_index].isdigit()
            ):
                number_end_index += 1

            repeat_count = int(
                first_encoded_string[
                    first_string_index:number_end_index
                ]
            )
            
            # Explore the possibility of using repeat count.
            if second_encoded_string[second_string_index].isdigit():
                number_end_index_2 = second_string_index
                while (
                    number_end_index_2 < second_string_length
                    and second_encoded_string[number_end_index_2].isdigit()
                ):
                    number_end_index_2 += 1

                repeat_count_2 = int(
                    second_encoded_string[
                        second_string_index:number_end_index_2
                    ]
                )
                
                # If both are digits, proceed with both repeat counts
                if repeat_count == repeat_count_2:
                    memo[(first_string_index, second_string_index)] = can_form_original_string(
                        number_end_index, number_end_index_2, current_string
                    )
                    return memo[(first_string_index, second_string_index)]
                else:
                    memo[(first_string_index, second_string_index)] = False
                    return False

            else:
                if (
                    second_string_index + repeat_count
                    <= second_string_length
                ):

                    substring = second_encoded_string[
                        second_string_index : second_string_index + repeat_count
                    ]

                    # Check if substring is all the same character
                    if len(set(substring)) == 1:

                        memo[(first_string_index, second_string_index)] = can_form_original_string(
                            number_end_index,
                            second_string_index + repeat_count,
                            current_string,
                        )

                        return memo[(first_string_index, second_string_index)]
                    else:
                        memo[(first_string_index, second_string_index)] = False
                        return False
                else:
                    memo[(first_string_index, second_string_index)] = False
                    return False
        else:
            # If the first encoded string has a character
            if second_encoded_string[second_string_index].isdigit():
                number_end_index_2 = second_string_index
                while (
                    number_end_index_2 < second_string_length
                    and second_encoded_string[number_end_index_2].isdigit()
                ):
                    number_end_index_2 += 1

                repeat_count_2 = int(
                    second_encoded_string[
                        second_string_index:number_end_index_2
                    ]
                )
                
                # Verify against a potentially repeating second string
                if (
                    first_string_index + repeat_count_2
                    <= first_string_length
                ):

                    substring = first_encoded_string[
                        first_string_index : first_string_index + repeat_count_2
                    ]

                    if len(set(substring)) == 1:
                        memo[(first_string_index, second_string_index)] = can_form_original_string(
                            first_string_index + repeat_count_2,
                            number_end_index_2,
                            current_string,
                        )

                        return memo[(first_string_index, second_string_index)]
                    else:
                        memo[(first_string_index, second_string_index)] = False
                        return False
                else:
                    memo[(first_string_index, second_string_index)] = False
                    return False

            else:

                # When both are letters, they must match
                if (
                    first_encoded_string[first_string_index]
                    == second_encoded_string[second_string_index]
                ):

                    # Check for identical characters
                    memo[(first_string_index, second_string_index)] = can_form_original_string(
                        first_string_index + 1,
                        second_string_index + 1,
                        current_string
                        + first_encoded_string[first_string_index],
                    )
                    return memo[(first_string_index, second_string_index)]

                else:
                    memo[(first_string_index, second_string_index)] = False
                    return False

    # Begin the recursive checking process
    return can_form_original_string(0, 0, "")

Big(O) Analysis

Time Complexity
O(m*n) – The algorithm explores possible original strings by traversing the two encoded strings concurrently. Let m and n represent the lengths of the two encoded strings, s1 and s2, respectively. In the worst-case scenario, the algorithm explores all possible combinations of expansions and character matches from both strings, potentially leading to nested explorations driven by numeric repetitions in the encoded strings. Therefore, the time complexity is approximately proportional to the product of the lengths of the two strings, giving O(m*n).
Space Complexity
O(N) – The algorithm uses recursion to explore all possible matches between the encoded strings. In the worst-case scenario, the recursion depth can be proportional to the length of the encoded strings, potentially exploring each character or number individually. Therefore, the maximum call stack size would be proportional to the length of the encoded strings which we will call N, leading to O(N) space usage for the recursion stack. No other significant auxiliary data structures are used.

Edge Cases

Both encoded strings are empty
How to Handle:
Return true; an empty original string matches two empty encodings.
One encoded string is empty, the other is not
How to Handle:
Return false; a non-empty encoding cannot result from an empty original.
Encoded strings have leading zeros in their numerical parts (e.g., '02a')
How to Handle:
Treat encoded strings with leading zeros as invalid encodings, return false.
The numerical part of an encoded string is larger than the length of the original string it represents.
How to Handle:
The number must represent repetition count and be checked against the original string length, return false when larger.
Encoded strings are very long, potentially leading to stack overflow with recursion.
How to Handle:
Use dynamic programming (memoization) to avoid redundant calculations and potential stack overflow with deep recursion.
The problem statement lacks clear constraints on input string length.
How to Handle:
Assume reasonable constraints (e.g., up to 200 characters), and clarify in interview if needed to consider space and time complexity.
An encoded string contains consecutive numbers followed by letters without being completely decoded.
How to Handle:
Ensure that the decoded string can be fully consumed by both encoded strings using backtracking.
An original string can have multiple possible encodings in each format but they do not match each other.
How to Handle:
Backtrack to explore different valid ways to encode the string using either of the encodings.