Taro Logo

Decode XORed Permutation

#482 Most AskedMedium
18 views
Topics:
ArraysBit Manipulation

There is an integer array perm that is a permutation of the first n positive integers, where n is always odd.

It was encoded into another integer array encoded of length n - 1, such that encoded[i] = perm[i] XOR perm[i + 1]. For example, if perm = [1,3,2], then encoded = [2,1].

Given the encoded array, return the original array perm. It is guaranteed that the answer exists and is unique.

Example 1:

Input: encoded = [3,1]
Output: [1,2,3]
Explanation: If perm = [1,2,3], then encoded = [1 XOR 2,2 XOR 3] = [3,1]

Example 2:

Input: encoded = [6,5,4,6]
Output: [2,4,1,5,3]

Constraints:

  • 3 <= n < 105
  • n is odd.
  • encoded.length == n - 1

Solution


Clarifying Questions

When you get asked this question in a real-life environment, it will often be ambiguous (especially at FAANG). Make sure to ask these questions in that case:

  1. What is the range of values in the original permutation `nums`? Will they always be positive integers?
  2. Can I assume the input array `encoded` is always valid, meaning it represents a difference array of a permutation?
  3. What should I return if the input `encoded` is empty or null?
  4. Is the original permutation guaranteed to contain distinct integers from 1 to n, where n is the length of the permutation?
  5. Are there any size limitations on the input array `encoded`?

Brute Force Solution

Approach

The brute force method for solving this problem involves trying every possible arrangement of numbers to see if it fits the rules. We generate all possible lists of numbers and then check if each list, when XORed as described in the problem, matches the given XORed sequence.

Here's how the algorithm would work step-by-step:

  1. First, generate all possible orderings of numbers from 1 up to a certain maximum number.
  2. For each ordering, perform the XOR operation between adjacent numbers, following the specific formula described in the problem.
  3. Compare the resulting sequence of XORed values with the sequence given as input.
  4. If the two sequences match exactly, we've found a correct solution and can return it.
  5. If none of the possible orderings produce a matching XORed sequence, then there might not be a solution, or we made an error in our assumptions.

Code Implementation

import itertools

def decode_xor_permutation_brute_force(xored_sequence):
    sequence_length = len(xored_sequence) + 1
    numbers = list(range(1, sequence_length + 1))
    
    # Generate all possible permutations of the numbers
    for permutation in itertools.permutations(numbers):
        
        generated_xored_sequence = []
        
        # Create the XORed sequence from the permutation
        for i in range(sequence_length - 1):
            generated_xored_sequence.append(permutation[i] ^ permutation[i+1])
        
        # Check to see if generated equals actual. If so, return the permutation
        if generated_xored_sequence == list(xored_sequence):
            return list(permutation)

    # No matching permutation found
    return []

Big(O) Analysis

Time Complexity
O(n * n!) – The brute force approach involves generating all permutations of numbers from 1 to n+1, where n is the length of the input `encoded` array. Generating all permutations takes O(n!) time. For each permutation, we then need to compute the XORed sequence, which involves iterating through the permutation of length n+1 and performing XOR operations between adjacent elements; this takes O(n) time. Therefore, the overall time complexity is O(n * n!).
Space Complexity
O(N!) – The brute force approach generates all possible permutations of numbers from 1 to N+1 (where N is the length of the input array), and stores them. Generating all permutations requires storing at least one permutation at a time, which can have up to (N+1) elements. Furthermore, the number of possible permutations is (N+1)!, so the algorithm implicitly has to store intermediate permutations for checking, with memory usage scaling factorially with N. Therefore, the space complexity is O(N!).

Optimal Solution

Approach

The problem gives us a sequence where each number is the combination of two adjacent numbers from a hidden list using a special operation. Instead of guessing the hidden list directly, we cleverly reconstruct it by figuring out the first number and then using the given sequence to find the rest.

Here's how the algorithm would work step-by-step:

  1. Recognize that we're missing the very first number from the original hidden list.
  2. Realize we can calculate the 'combined' value of *all* the numbers in the original hidden list, even though we don't know them all yet.
  3. Calculate the combined value of all numbers from 1 up to the length of the original hidden list.
  4. Use the combined value of all numbers in the original hidden list and the 'combined' value that we calculated to figure out what the first number is.
  5. Once we have the first number, use the given sequence to find the second number, then the third, and so on, until we have reconstructed the entire original hidden list.

Code Implementation

def decode_xored_permutation(encoded_list):
    list_length = len(encoded_list) + 1
    total_xor = 0
    for i in range(1, list_length + 1):
        total_xor ^= i

    encoded_xor = 0

    # XOR all encoded values at even indices
    for i in range(1, list_length - 1, 2):
        encoded_xor ^= encoded_list[i]

    first_element = total_xor ^ encoded_xor

    # Initialize the decoded permutation with the first element
    decoded_permutation = [first_element]

    # Reconstruct the permutation from the encoded list
    for i in range(list_length - 1):
        next_element = decoded_permutation[-1] ^ encoded_list[i]
        decoded_permutation.append(next_element)

    return decoded_permutation

Big(O) Analysis

Time Complexity
O(n) – The algorithm iterates through the input array of length n-1 to compute the XOR of elements at even indices. It then calculates the XOR of all numbers from 1 to n. Finally, it reconstructs the permutation in another loop of length n-1. Thus, the operations scale linearly with the input size n, resulting in O(n) time complexity.
Space Complexity
O(N) – The algorithm reconstructs the original hidden list and stores it in a new list. The size of this list is equal to the length of the original hidden list, which we can denote as N. Therefore, the auxiliary space used by the algorithm is proportional to the size of the input permutation. All other variables used take constant space and do not depend on N.

Edge Cases

Null or empty `encoded` array
How to Handle:
Return an empty array or throw an exception as there's nothing to decode.
`encoded` array of size 1
How to Handle:
Return an empty array since you can't derive a permutation from a single XORed value.
`encoded` array length is not of the form n-1 for a permutation of length n
How to Handle:
Throw an exception indicating invalid input format, as it doesn't represent a valid XORed permutation.
Integer overflow in XOR calculations (if the numbers in the permutation can be large)
How to Handle:
Use a data type with a larger range (e.g., long) or perform overflow checks during XOR operations.
The decoded permutation exceeds the size limits (e.g. maximum array size)
How to Handle:
Throw an exception or return an error code to indicate a size limit violation.
The calculated first element of the permutation leads to values outside the range [1, n]
How to Handle:
Check if calculated initial value is within range and return error if not.
The encoded array produces a permutation with duplicate numbers
How to Handle:
Verify that the decoded permutation contains unique numbers within the correct range; return error if not.
Large input sizes (e.g., `encoded` array with millions of elements)
How to Handle:
Ensure algorithm has linear time complexity to efficiently decode without performance degradation.
0/1718 completed