Taro Logo

Faulty Sensor

#393 Most AskedEasy
14 views
Topics:
Arrays

An experiment was conducted to determine the precise time at which an aircraft will be blown off course due to crosswinds. The experiment involves flying the aircraft multiple times and recording the sensor data at each time point. However, the on-board sensor used to collect the data is faulty. So the data reported by the sensor might be incorrect.

You are given two arrays sensor1 and sensor2, where sensor1[i] and sensor2[i] are the sensor readings at the ith time point.

If the sensor is working correctly, and the aircraft is not blown off course, then the two sensors should report the same values. Otherwise, the aircraft is considered to be blown off course.

You need to find the first time point at which the aircraft is blown off course. More formally, you need to find the smallest index i such that:

  • sensor1[i] != sensor2[i], and
  • after this time point, all subsequent values of sensor1 and sensor2 are different i.e. for all j > i then sensor1[j] != sensor2[j].

Return the index of the time point when the aircraft is blown off course. If the aircraft was never blown off course, return -1.

Example 1:

Input: sensor1 = [2,3,4,5,6], sensor2 = [2,3,4,5,6]
Output: -1
Explanation: There is no time point at which the values of the two sensors are different. 

Example 2:

Input: sensor1 = [2,2,2,2,3], sensor2 = [2,2,2,2,4]
Output: 4
Explanation: The aircraft is blown off course at the 4th time point because sensor1[4] != sensor2[4], and after this time point, all subsequent values of sensor1 and sensor2 are different.

Example 3:

Input: sensor1 = [2,2,2,2,3], sensor2 = [2,2,2,2,3]
Output: -1
Explanation: The aircraft is never blown off course. After the 4th time point, the values of the two sensors are the same.

Constraints:

  • n == sensor1.length == sensor2.length
  • 1 <= n <= 100
  • 1 <= sensor1[i], sensor2[i] <= 100

Solution


Clarifying Questions

When you get asked this question in a real-life environment, it will often be ambiguous (especially at FAANG). Make sure to ask these questions in that case:

  1. What is the data type and range of values for the sensor readings in the input array? Can they be negative, zero, or floating-point numbers?
  2. What should I return if no pair of faulty sensors is found that meet the criteria for being deemed faulty?
  3. Are there any specific requirements on how the faulty sensor pair must be determined, or can I choose any valid pair if multiple exist?
  4. What is the expected size of the input array? Is memory usage a significant concern?
  5. Can you provide an example input and corresponding expected output to further illustrate the problem?

Brute Force Solution

Approach

The brute force method for the faulty sensor problem means we will meticulously try every single possible sensor to see if it's the faulty one. We will test each sensor as the faulty one, and check if it makes the remaining sensors' readings consistent.

Here's how the algorithm would work step-by-step:

  1. Assume the first sensor is faulty.
  2. Based on this assumption, see if the readings from the other sensors make logical sense together. Check if they are all internally consistent.
  3. If they aren't consistent, then the first sensor could be the faulty one, so remember this outcome.
  4. Now, assume the second sensor is faulty.
  5. Again, check if the readings from all the other sensors are consistent with each other.
  6. Keep repeating this process, each time assuming a different sensor is the faulty one.
  7. After trying every sensor, look back at the results and find the sensor that, when considered faulty, makes all the other sensors have consistent readings.
  8. If there is only one such sensor, then that must be the faulty sensor. If there are more than one such sensor, then you can't find out which sensor is the culprit.

Code Implementation

def find_faulty_sensor_brute_force(sensor_readings):
    number_of_sensors = len(sensor_readings)
    faulty_sensor_candidates = []

    for suspected_faulty_sensor in range(number_of_sensors):
        # Assume one sensor is faulty at a time
        consistent = True
        other_sensor_readings = []
        for index in range(number_of_sensors):
            if index != suspected_faulty_sensor:
                other_sensor_readings.append(sensor_readings[index])

        # Check consistency amongst the other sensors
        if len(other_sensor_readings) > 1:
            first_reading = other_sensor_readings[0]
            for reading in other_sensor_readings[1:]:
                if reading != first_reading:
                    consistent = False
                    break

        # Keep track of potential faulty sensor
        if consistent:
            faulty_sensor_candidates.append(suspected_faulty_sensor)

    if len(faulty_sensor_candidates) == 1:
        return faulty_sensor_candidates[0]
    else:
        # If we cant find the faulty sensor
        return None

Big(O) Analysis

Time Complexity
O(n^2) – The algorithm iterates through each of the n sensors, assuming each one is faulty in turn. For each such assumption, the algorithm checks the consistency of the readings from the remaining (n-1) sensors. This consistency check involves comparing pairs of these remaining sensors, requiring O(n) operations in the worst case for each sensor being considered faulty. Therefore, the total number of operations is approximately n * n, resulting in a time complexity of O(n^2).
Space Complexity
O(1) – The algorithm iterates through each sensor, but it doesn't create any auxiliary data structures that scale with the number of sensors (N). It checks consistency based on the other sensor readings but does not store intermediate results in a way that depends on N. The space used for variables to keep track of the current sensor being tested and a flag indicating consistency remains constant regardless of the input size N. Therefore, the auxiliary space complexity is O(1).

Optimal Solution

Approach

The problem involves comparing two lists of sensor readings to identify a faulty sensor. The optimal approach leverages the differences between the readings to quickly pinpoint the malfunctioning sensor by focusing on inconsistencies rather than exhaustively comparing every value.

Here's how the algorithm would work step-by-step:

  1. Look for the first instance where the two lists of sensor readings disagree.
  2. From that point onwards, check if the readings from one of the lists remain constant while the other list continues to have varying values. The unchanging list likely represents readings from the faulty sensor.
  3. If neither list stays constant after the first disagreement, compare the lists again and count how many times each reading appears in each list.
  4. The list containing more repetitive readings indicates the readings from the faulty sensor, which is likely stuck or providing a limited range of values.
  5. Confirm the faulty sensor by ensuring that from a certain point onwards, the 'good' sensor consistently deviates from a fixed pattern, while the other sensor remains stuck on repeating limited values.

Code Implementation

def find_faulty_sensor(sensor_1_readings, sensor_2_readings):
    first_disagreement_index = -1
    for index in range(min(len(sensor_1_readings), len(sensor_2_readings))):
        if sensor_1_readings[index] != sensor_2_readings[index]:
            first_disagreement_index = index
            break

    if first_disagreement_index == -1:
        return None

    # Check if one sensor remains constant after the first disagreement.
    sensor_1_constant = True
    sensor_2_constant = True

    if first_disagreement_index < len(sensor_1_readings) - 1:
        first_value_sensor_1 = sensor_1_readings[first_disagreement_index]
        for index in range(first_disagreement_index + 1, len(sensor_1_readings)):
            if sensor_1_readings[index] != first_value_sensor_1:
                sensor_1_constant = False
                break

    if first_disagreement_index < len(sensor_2_readings) - 1:
        first_value_sensor_2 = sensor_2_readings[first_disagreement_index]
        for index in range(first_disagreement_index + 1, len(sensor_2_readings)):
            if sensor_2_readings[index] != first_value_sensor_2:
                sensor_2_constant = False
                break

    if sensor_1_constant:
        return 1
    if sensor_2_constant:
        return 2

    # Count the occurrences of each reading in each list.
    sensor_1_counts = {}
    for reading in sensor_1_readings:
        sensor_1_counts[reading] = sensor_1_counts.get(reading, 0) + 1

    sensor_2_counts = {}
    for reading in sensor_2_readings:
        sensor_2_counts[reading] = sensor_2_counts.get(reading, 0) + 1

    sensor_1_repetition = sum(count > 1 for count in sensor_1_counts.values())
    sensor_2_repetition = sum(count > 1 for count in sensor_2_counts.values())

    # If one sensor has more repetitive readings, it's likely faulty.
    if sensor_1_repetition > sensor_2_repetition:
        return 1
    elif sensor_2_repetition > sensor_1_repetition:
        return 2

    # We found a discrepancy and require deeper analysis
    # to identify the faulty sensor based on deviations.
    discrepancy_start_index = first_disagreement_index
    if discrepancy_start_index == -1:
        return None

    readings_after_discrepancy_1 = sensor_1_readings[discrepancy_start_index:]
    readings_after_discrepancy_2 = sensor_2_readings[discrepancy_start_index:]

    if len(readings_after_discrepancy_1) == 0 or len(readings_after_discrepancy_2) == 0:
        return None

    # Checking for consistency after disagreement
    first_reading_1 = readings_after_discrepancy_1[0]
    consistent_1 = all(reading == first_reading_1 for reading in readings_after_discrepancy_1)
    first_reading_2 = readings_after_discrepancy_2[0]
    consistent_2 = all(reading == first_reading_2 for reading in readings_after_discrepancy_2)

    # Return sensor 1 or 2 depending on who is consistent
    if consistent_1:
        return 1
    if consistent_2:
        return 2

    return None

Big(O) Analysis

Time Complexity
O(n) – The algorithm first finds the first point of disagreement between the two lists, which takes O(n) time in the worst case, where n is the length of the lists. After finding the disagreement, it checks if either list remains constant. This check also takes O(n) time in the worst case, as it may need to iterate through the rest of the lists. If neither list remains constant, it compares the lists and counts the frequency of each reading. The counting process is also O(n). Therefore, since each step takes at most O(n) time and they are executed sequentially, the overall time complexity is O(n).
Space Complexity
O(N) – In step 3, if neither list stays constant, we need to count the occurrences of each reading in both lists. This is done using hash maps (or dictionaries). In the worst-case scenario, all sensor readings are unique, requiring us to store each of the N readings (where N is the length of the input lists) and their counts in the hash maps. Therefore, the space complexity is proportional to N.

Edge Cases

Null or empty input array
How to Handle:
Return an empty list or throw an IllegalArgumentException as there are no elements to compare.
Input array with only one element
How to Handle:
Return an empty list because a pair requires at least two elements.
Input array with all elements being identical
How to Handle:
The algorithm should correctly identify and handle if a pair exists with the target value.
Target value smaller than the smallest element in the array
How to Handle:
The algorithm should correctly identify that no valid pair exists and return an empty list.
Target value larger than the sum of the two largest elements in the array
How to Handle:
The algorithm should correctly identify that no valid pair exists and return an empty list.
Integer overflow when adding elements
How to Handle:
Use long data type during the sum to prevent integer overflow.
Array containing extremely large numbers
How to Handle:
Consider the space complexity for storing intermediate results.
Array contains negative numbers
How to Handle:
The algorithm should correctly handle negative numbers when calculating the sum and searching for pairs.
0/1124 completed