Taro Logo

Find the Kth Smallest Sum of a Matrix With Sorted Rows

Hard
Asked by:
Profile picture
Profile picture
104 views
Topics:
ArraysBinary SearchGreedy Algorithms

You are given an m x n matrix mat that has its rows sorted in non-decreasing order and an integer k.

You are allowed to choose exactly one element from each row to form an array.

Return the kth smallest array sum among all possible arrays.

Example 1:

Input: mat = [[1,3,11],[2,4,6]], k = 5
Output: 7
Explanation: Choosing one element from each row, the first k smallest sum are:
[1,2], [1,4], [3,2], [3,4], [1,6]. Where the 5th sum is 7.

Example 2:

Input: mat = [[1,3,11],[2,4,6]], k = 9
Output: 17

Example 3:

Input: mat = [[1,10,10],[1,4,5],[2,3,6]], k = 7
Output: 9
Explanation: Choosing one element from each row, the first k smallest sum are:
[1,1,2], [1,1,3], [1,4,2], [1,4,3], [1,1,6], [1,5,2], [1,5,3]. Where the 7th sum is 9.  

Constraints:

  • m == mat.length
  • n == mat.length[i]
  • 1 <= m, n <= 40
  • 1 <= mat[i][j] <= 5000
  • 1 <= k <= min(200, nm)
  • mat[i] is a non-decreasing array.

Solution


Clarifying Questions

When you get asked this question in a real-life environment, it will often be ambiguous (especially at FAANG). Make sure to ask these questions in that case:

  1. What are the constraints on the dimensions of the matrix (number of rows and columns), and what is the maximum value for K?
  2. Can the values within the matrix be negative, zero, or floating-point numbers, or are they strictly positive integers?
  3. Is K guaranteed to be a valid value (i.e., within the possible range of sum combinations), or should I handle cases where K is larger than the number of possible sums?
  4. If there are duplicate sums, should I treat them as distinct when determining the Kth smallest sum, or should I consider their multiplicity?
  5. What is the expected format of the input matrix (e.g., a list of lists, a NumPy array), and can I assume the input is always valid (non-null, properly formatted)?
  6. Are the rows strictly sorted in ascending order?

Brute Force Solution

Approach

We need to find the Kth smallest sum we can make by picking one number from each row of a grid. The brute force approach is like trying every possible combination of numbers, calculating the sum for each, and then finding the Kth smallest among all those sums.

Here's how the algorithm would work step-by-step:

  1. Imagine you have a series of choices to make. For the first row, you pick one number.
  2. Then, for the second row, you pick one number, and do this for all the rows.
  3. Calculate the total sum of all the numbers you picked across all rows.
  4. Store this sum.
  5. Repeat steps one through four, but this time, pick a *different* set of numbers from the rows.
  6. Keep doing this until you've tried *every single possible combination* of picking one number from each row and calculated the sum.
  7. Now you have a big list of all the possible sums.
  8. Sort this list from smallest to largest.
  9. The number at the Kth position in this sorted list (counting from 1) is the answer.

Code Implementation

def find_kth_smallest_sum(matrix, k_value):
    possible_sums = []

    def generate_sums(current_sum, row_index):
        # If we've reached the end of the matrix, add the sum to the list
        if row_index == len(matrix):
            possible_sums.append(current_sum)
            return

        for column_index in range(len(matrix[row_index])):
            generate_sums(current_sum + matrix[row_index][column_index], row_index + 1)

    # Start generating sums from the first row
    generate_sums(0, 0)

    # Sort the sums to find the kth smallest
    possible_sums.sort()

    # Return the kth smallest sum
    return possible_sums[k_value - 1]

Big(O) Analysis

Time Complexity
O(m^n log(m^n)) – The algorithm iterates through all possible combinations of picking one element from each of the n rows, where each row has m elements. This results in m^n possible sums. Then, the algorithm sorts these m^n sums, which takes O(m^n log(m^n)) time using a typical sorting algorithm like mergesort or quicksort. The dominant operation is the sorting step, so the overall time complexity is O(m^n log(m^n)).
Space Complexity
O(N*M) – The brute force approach described requires storing all possible sums calculated from every combination of numbers picked from the rows. Since we are picking one number from each of the N rows, where each row has some length M (we'll assume all rows have a maximum of M elements for simplicity), this would lead to M^N possible sums in the worst case. Storing these sums requires a data structure, like a list or array, to hold these intermediate sums before sorting. After calculating these sums, sorting this list of sums (containing at most M^N elements) to find the Kth smallest element dominates the space complexity in this brute force case. In the given explanation N is the number of rows and M is the maximum number of columns across all rows. Therefore, the space complexity is approximated by O(M^N) to store all possible sums, but because we only need to hold K sums at most, the auxiliary space is O(K). However, in the worst case if K is M^N, then it simplifies to O(M^N). Because we are considering K sums and assuming that K can grow to be M * N in the worst case, or even larger, and considering the constraint that M can be much larger than N, then this worst-case scenario space complexity simplifies to O(M^N), because each of the M^N sums requires space. Storing up to K sums leads to a complexity of O(K), so O(N*M) is incorrect but more reasonable that O(1), but let's try and do better. The brute force solution iterates all combinations of M values across N rows, calculating and storing the possible sums, so if M is large enough, storing M^N sums will lead to space O(M^N). Since we only are storing the sums in a single list, sorting has minimal space impact on the overall space complexity, we need to consider the auxiliary space needed to store all possible sums before sorting. Because this approach could involve constructing and storing at most M^N sums, and this space is auxiliary, then the space complexity for this brute force solution is O(M^N). Because storing the M * N sums dominates the memory use, the space complexity is O(M^N) when N is the number of rows and M is the maximum number of columns of the matrix.

Optimal Solution

Approach

The key idea is to avoid calculating all possible sums, which would be too slow. We maintain a 'pool' of the smallest sums we've seen so far and efficiently update it as we consider elements from each row, always keeping the pool sorted and limited to the 'k' smallest sums.

Here's how the algorithm would work step-by-step:

  1. Start with an initial pool containing only the sum of the first element of each row.
  2. For each subsequent row in the matrix:
  3. Create a new, empty pool to hold potential sums.
  4. Combine each existing sum in the current pool with each element in the current row to generate new sums.
  5. Add these new sums to the new pool, but only keep the smallest 'k' sums. It's crucial to avoid storing every single sum.
  6. Replace the current pool with the new pool of smallest sums.
  7. After processing all rows, the 'k'-th smallest sum will be the last element of the 'k' smallest sums you have.

Code Implementation

def find_kth_smallest_sum(matrix, k):
    number_of_rows = len(matrix)

    # Initialize the pool with the sum of first elements
    current_smallest_sums = [matrix[i][0] for i in range(number_of_rows)]
    current_smallest_sums.sort()
    current_smallest_sums = current_smallest_sums[:k]

    for row_index in range(1, number_of_rows):
        new_smallest_sums = []

        # Generate new sums by combining existing sums and row elements.
        for current_sum in current_smallest_sums:
            for element in matrix[row_index]:
                new_smallest_sums.append(current_sum + element)

        new_smallest_sums.sort()

        # Limit the pool to only the k smallest sums
        current_smallest_sums = new_smallest_sums[:k]

    # The kth smallest sum is the last element of k smallest sums
    return current_smallest_sums[k - 1]

Big(O) Analysis

Time Complexity
O(m * k * log(k)) – The algorithm iterates through each row of the matrix (m rows). In the inner loop, it combines the current 'k' smallest sums with each element of the current row (at most k elements) which generates k * k new sums. To keep only the smallest k sums, a sorting operation is performed which has a cost of O(k * log(k)). Thus each row requires k * k * log(k) time, but as we only keep at most k elements from the row we can reduce the operations. Multiplying by the number of rows leads to a total time complexity of O(m * k * k). However we can optimize using a priority queue so the operation to keep only k smallest sums becomes O(k log(k)), resulting in O(m * k * log(k)).
Space Complexity
O(k) – The algorithm uses a 'pool' to store the 'k' smallest sums encountered so far. This pool is updated after processing each row, but its size is always limited to 'k'. Therefore, the space complexity is determined by the maximum size of this pool, which is O(k), where k is the input parameter representing the k-th smallest sum to find. No other significant auxiliary space is used beyond this pool.

Edge Cases

Input matrix is null or empty
How to Handle:
Return an empty list or null if the input matrix is null or empty, as there are no sums to calculate.
Input matrix has zero rows or zero columns
How to Handle:
Return an empty list or null if the number of rows or columns is zero, as no sums can be formed.
K is less than or equal to 0
How to Handle:
Throw an IllegalArgumentException or return an empty list if K is not a positive integer.
K is greater than the total number of possible sums (product of row lengths)
How to Handle:
Return the list of all possible sums in ascending order if K is larger than the total number of sums.
Matrix contains duplicate numbers within rows
How to Handle:
The algorithm should correctly handle duplicate numbers in rows, as it considers all possible combinations.
Matrix contains negative numbers
How to Handle:
The algorithm should correctly calculate sums even with negative numbers in the matrix.
Integer overflow when calculating sums
How to Handle:
Use a larger data type like long to store the sums to avoid integer overflow.
Large matrix dimensions leading to memory exhaustion when generating all sums
How to Handle:
Use a priority queue (min-heap) to keep track of the k smallest sums, instead of generating all possible sums.