Taro Logo

Make Costs of Paths Equal in a Binary Tree

#375 Most AskedMedium
14 views
Topics:
TreesDynamic ProgrammingGreedy Algorithms

You are given an integer n representing the number of nodes in a perfect binary tree consisting of nodes numbered from 1 to n. The root of the tree is node 1 and each node i in the tree has two children where the left child is the node 2 * i and the right child is 2 * i + 1.

Each node in the tree also has a cost represented by a given 0-indexed integer array cost of size n where cost[i] is the cost of node i + 1. You are allowed to increment the cost of any node by 1 any number of times.

Return the minimum number of increments you need to make the cost of paths from the root to each leaf node equal.

Note:

  • A perfect binary tree is a tree where each node, except the leaf nodes, has exactly 2 children.
  • The cost of a path is the sum of costs of nodes in the path.

Example 1:

Input: n = 7, cost = [1,5,2,2,3,3,1]
Output: 6
Explanation: We can do the following increments:
- Increase the cost of node 4 one time.
- Increase the cost of node 3 three times.
- Increase the cost of node 7 two times.
Each path from the root to a leaf will have a total cost of 9.
The total increments we did is 1 + 3 + 2 = 6.
It can be shown that this is the minimum answer we can achieve.

Example 2:

Input: n = 3, cost = [5,3,3]
Output: 0
Explanation: The two paths already have equal total costs, so no increments are needed.

Constraints:

  • 3 <= n <= 105
  • n + 1 is a power of 2
  • cost.length == n
  • 1 <= cost[i] <= 104

Solution


Clarifying Questions

When you get asked this question in a real-life environment, it will often be ambiguous (especially at FAANG). Make sure to ask these questions in that case:

  1. What are the possible ranges for the node costs in the `costs` array? Could they be negative?
  2. What is the maximum size of the `costs` array? This will help me understand the potential depth of the binary tree.
  3. If the input `costs` array is empty, what should I return?
  4. Could you clarify the definition of 'root-to-leaf' path? Specifically, are we considering only paths from the absolute root (costs[0]) or is the root relative to subtrees?
  5. If there are multiple ways to minimize the total increment needed to make all root-to-leaf path costs equal, is any valid solution acceptable?

Brute Force Solution

Approach

The problem asks us to adjust the values within a tree so that all paths from the root to the leaves have the same total cost. A brute force approach explores all possible adjustments to find the one that works, without trying to be clever or efficient.

Here's how the algorithm would work step-by-step:

  1. Consider every possible value change for the very first node (the root).
  2. For each of those root changes, consider every possible value change for the next nodes down the tree.
  3. Continue this process, exploring every possible value change for every node in the tree.
  4. For each complete set of changes to all the nodes, calculate the cost of every path from the root to a leaf.
  5. Check if all the path costs are equal. If they are, then this set of changes is a potential solution.
  6. Keep track of all sets of changes that result in equal path costs.
  7. From all the sets of changes that give equal path costs, choose the one that requires the smallest total change to the node values. This is the best solution.

Code Implementation

class Node:
    def __init__(self, value, left=None, right=None):
        self.value = value
        self.left = left
        self.right = right

def make_costs_of_paths_equal_brute_force(root):
    minimum_cost = float('inf')
    best_tree = None

    def calculate_path_cost(node, current_cost):
        if not node:
            return [current_cost]
        
        current_cost += node.value

        if not node.left and not node.right:
            return [current_cost]

        path_costs = []
        path_costs.extend(calculate_path_cost(node.left, current_cost))
        path_costs.extend(calculate_path_cost(node.right, current_cost))
        return path_costs

    def calculate_cost_to_change(original_root, modified_root):
        if not original_root:
            return 0
        
        cost = abs(original_root.value - modified_root.value)
        
        if original_root.left and modified_root.left:
            cost += calculate_cost_to_change(original_root.left, modified_root.left)
        elif original_root.left or modified_root.left:
            cost = float('inf')
            return cost
            
        if original_root.right and modified_root.right:
            cost += calculate_cost_to_change(original_root.right, modified_root.right)
        elif original_root.right or modified_root.right:
            cost = float('inf')
            return cost

        return cost

    def explore_tree_configurations(current_root):
        nonlocal minimum_cost, best_tree

        # Need to explore many possible values
        for root_value in range(current_root.value - 5, current_root.value + 6):
            current_root.value = root_value
            
            if current_root.left:
                # Explore values for the left subtree
                for left_value in range(current_root.left.value - 5, current_root.left.value + 6):
                    current_root.left.value = left_value
                    if current_root.right:
                        # Explore values for the right subtree
                        for right_value in range(current_root.right.value - 5, current_root.right.value + 6):
                            current_root.right.value = right_value
                            path_costs = calculate_path_cost(root, 0)
                            if len(set(path_costs)) == 1:
                                cost_to_change = calculate_cost_to_change(root, root)

                                # We compare this configuration to other configurations
                                if cost_to_change < minimum_cost:
                                    minimum_cost = cost_to_change
                                    best_tree = root
                            # reset value
                            current_root.right.value = right_value - (right_value - current_root.right.value)

                    else:
                        path_costs = calculate_path_cost(root, 0)
                        if len(set(path_costs)) == 1:
                            cost_to_change = calculate_cost_to_change(root, root)
                            if cost_to_change < minimum_cost:
                                minimum_cost = cost_to_change
                                best_tree = root
                    # reset value
                    current_root.left.value = left_value - (left_value - current_root.left.value)
            else:
                path_costs = calculate_path_cost(root, 0)
                if len(set(path_costs)) == 1:
                    cost_to_change = calculate_cost_to_change(root, root)
                    if cost_to_change < minimum_cost:
                        minimum_cost = cost_to_change
                        best_tree = root

    explore_tree_configurations(root)

    return minimum_cost

Big(O) Analysis

Time Complexity
O(k^n) – The described brute force approach explores every possible value change for each node in the tree. Let n be the number of nodes in the binary tree and k be the number of possible values each node can take. Since we are considering every possible value change for every node, we have a branching factor of k at each of the n nodes. Therefore, the algorithm explores k^n possibilities. For each of these possibilities, the algorithm calculates the cost of each path which is O(n), and checks if all path costs are equal. Thus, the overall time complexity becomes O(k^n).
Space Complexity
O(N * M) – The algorithm explores every possible value change for each of the N nodes in the binary tree. For each node, it potentially considers M different values to try (the problem description does not specify the possible values to try but for the brute force to work, we need some number of possible values M). For each combination of changes, we calculate the cost of every path from the root to a leaf. These costs are temporarily stored, and in the worst case, we might have to store the costs for every leaf. In a balanced binary tree, approximately half the nodes are leaves, which is still O(N), leading to a total auxiliary space complexity of O(N * M) to store these intermediate values and the different tree configurations during the search.

Optimal Solution

Approach

The best way to solve this is to work from the bottom up. We figure out the required cost increases needed at each step to make all paths from the root to the leaves have equal cost, ensuring we only increase costs and propagate information efficiently.

Here's how the algorithm would work step-by-step:

  1. Start by looking at the very bottom of the tree, the leaves. We don't need to do anything at the leaves because they are the end of each path.
  2. Move up to the parents of the leaves. For each parent, find the maximum cost of all paths from that parent down to the leaves.
  3. For each child of the parent, figure out how much we need to increase the cost along the path from the parent to that specific child so that all paths from the parent to the leaves have the same maximum cost.
  4. Add these required cost increases to the parent's cost. This ensures that all paths from this parent down to a leaf have equal cost.
  5. Repeat this process, moving up the tree one level at a time. Each time, we adjust the cost of a node based on the maximum costs of its children.
  6. Continue doing this until we reach the very top, the root of the tree.
  7. The total of all the increases we made as we moved upwards is the final answer: the minimum cost to make all paths from the root to any leaf have equal cost.

Code Implementation

class Node:
    def __init__(self, value):
        self.value = value
        self.left = None
        self.right = None

def min_cost_to_equalize_paths(root):
    total_cost = 0

    def dfs(node):
        nonlocal total_cost

        # Base case: leaf node
        if not node:
            return 0

        left_subtree_cost = dfs(node.left)
        right_subtree_cost = dfs(node.right)

        # Determine the maximum path cost from this node down.
        max_subtree_cost = max(left_subtree_cost, right_subtree_cost)

        # Calculate the cost to add to the current node.
        cost_to_add = max_subtree_cost - node.value

        # Accumulate the total cost.
        if cost_to_add > 0:
            total_cost += cost_to_add

        # Update the current node's value.
        node.value += cost_to_add

        # The path cost to this node's parent is its value plus the max cost from its subtrees.
        return node.value

    dfs(root)
    return total_cost

Big(O) Analysis

Time Complexity
O(n) – The algorithm processes each node in the binary tree exactly once. At each node, it calculates the maximum path cost among its children and potentially updates the node's cost based on this maximum. Since the number of nodes in the tree is represented by n, and each node is visited a constant amount of time, the overall time complexity is directly proportional to n. Therefore, the time complexity is O(n).
Space Complexity
O(H) – The algorithm implicitly utilizes the call stack due to its recursive nature, where H is the height of the binary tree. In the worst-case scenario (a skewed tree), the recursion depth can be proportional to the number of nodes (N), leading to a stack space of O(N). However, for a balanced tree, the height H is logarithmic, resulting in a stack space of O(log N). Therefore, the auxiliary space complexity is O(H), representing the maximum depth of the recursive calls stored on the call stack.

Edge Cases

Empty input array (costs is null or has length 0)
How to Handle:
Return 0 as there are no paths to adjust when the tree is empty.
Input array with only one element
How to Handle:
Return 0, as a single-node tree already has equal path costs (only one path).
Input array with two elements
How to Handle:
Return the absolute difference between the two node costs since they're children of a single root.
All costs are identical
How to Handle:
Return 0, as all root-to-leaf paths already have equal costs.
Costs contain negative numbers
How to Handle:
The solution should handle negative costs correctly; the differences are still calculated using absolute values.
Integer overflow when calculating differences between costs
How to Handle:
Use long data type to store the path cost and total increment to prevent overflow.
Large input size impacting memory or stack usage if recursion is used
How to Handle:
Use iterative approach to avoid stack overflow errors for very large trees or consider tail-recursive optimizations if recursion is absolutely required.
Skewed cost distribution (e.g., one path has very high costs compared to others)
How to Handle:
The algorithm should correctly adjust the costs along the lower-cost paths to match the highest cost path, minimizing overall increment.
0/425 completed