Taro Logo

Maximum Number That Sum of the Prices Is Less Than or Equal to K

#1116 Most AskedMedium
16 views
Topics:
Bit ManipulationBinary Search

You are given an integer k and an integer x. The price of a number num is calculated by the count of set bits at positions x, 2x, 3x, etc., in its binary representation, starting from the least significant bit. The following table contains examples of how price is calculated.

x num Binary Representation Price
1 13 000001101 3
2 13 000001101 1
2 233 011101001 3
3 13 000001101 1
3 362 101101010 2

The accumulated price of num is the total price of numbers from 1 to num. num is considered cheap if its accumulated price is less than or equal to k.

Return the greatest cheap number.

Example 1:

Input: k = 9, x = 1

Output: 6

Explanation:

As shown in the table below, 6 is the greatest cheap number.

x num Binary Representation Price Accumulated Price
1 1 001 1 1
1 2 010 1 2
1 3 011 2 4
1 4 100 1 5
1 5 101 2 7
1 6 110 2 9
1 7 111 3 12

Example 2:

Input: k = 7, x = 2

Output: 9

Explanation:

As shown in the table below, 9 is the greatest cheap number.

x num Binary Representation Price Accumulated Price
2 1 0001 0 0
2 2 0010 1 1
2 3 0011 1 2
2 4 0100 0 2
2 5 0101 0 2
2 6 0110 1 3
2 7 0111 1 4
2 8 1000 1 5
2 9 1001 1 6
2 10 1010 2 8

Constraints:

  • 1 <= k <= 1015
  • 1 <= x <= 8

Solution


Clarifying Questions

When you get asked this question in a real-life environment, it will often be ambiguous (especially at FAANG). Make sure to ask these questions in that case:

  1. What is the maximum possible value of k?
  2. Is k always non-negative?
  3. If no number exists whose digit sum is less than or equal to k, what should the function return?
  4. Are there any specific constraints on the size of the output number (e.g., number of digits)?
  5. Are we looking for the absolute largest number, or just a very large number whose cost is <= k (perhaps allowing for some approximations if needed due to potential performance limitations)?

Brute Force Solution

Approach

The brute force strategy is to try every possible number one by one, from the largest possible number down to 1. For each number, we calculate the sum of prices. If the sum of the prices is less than or equal to K, we have found our answer.

Here's how the algorithm would work step-by-step:

  1. Start with the largest possible number you could have.
  2. Calculate the sum of the prices for that number.
  3. Check if the sum of prices is less than or equal to K.
  4. If it is, then you've found the maximum number that satisfies the condition and you're done.
  5. If it's not, reduce the number by one.
  6. Repeat steps 2 through 5 with the new, smaller number.
  7. Keep doing this until you either find a number whose price sum is less than or equal to K, or you reach 1 (in which case, if 1's price is <= K, then 1 is the answer).

Code Implementation

def find_maximum_number(k_value):
    maximum_possible_number = k_value

    # Iterate down from the maximum possible number
    for current_number in range(maximum_possible_number, 0, -1):

        price_sum = calculate_price_sum(current_number)

        # Check if the price sum is within the limit
        if price_sum <= k_value:
            # This number works so return it immediately
            return current_number

    # If no number is found, return 0.
    return 0

def calculate_price_sum(number):
    price = 0
    string_number = str(number)
    for digit_char in string_number:
        digit = int(digit_char)
        price += digit
    return price

Big(O) Analysis

Time Complexity
O(n*log(n)) – The brute force approach iterates downwards from a maximum possible number, let's denote this number as 'n'. For each number 'i' in this iteration, we must calculate the sum of the prices. Assuming calculating the price for a single number takes O(log(i)) time due to some logarithmic calculation or accessing a precomputed array with binary search of size i, the overall time complexity becomes a sum of log(i) from i=n down to 1. This summation is roughly bounded by n*log(n) as the log function grows slowly. Therefore, the overall time complexity is O(n*log(n)).
Space Complexity
O(1) – The brute force solution, as described, does not utilize any auxiliary data structures. It iteratively decrements a number and calculates the sum of prices. The number itself, and any intermediate variables used in calculating the price sum, occupy a constant amount of space regardless of the maximum possible number or K. Therefore, the space complexity is constant.

Optimal Solution

Approach

The most efficient approach involves using binary search to quickly find the largest possible number. Instead of checking every number one by one, this method smartly narrows down the range of possibilities, leading to a faster solution.

Here's how the algorithm would work step-by-step:

  1. First, understand the lowest and highest possible numbers you could potentially pick from. These will be the starting points for our search range.
  2. Calculate the middle number within this range.
  3. Determine the 'price' of this middle number according to the problem's specific pricing function (e.g., counting set bits, etc.).
  4. Compare the 'price' of this middle number to the maximum amount you can spend (K).
  5. If the 'price' is less than or equal to K, then you know that the largest possible number could be this middle number, or even higher! So, narrow your search range to the upper half (from the middle number to the highest number).
  6. If the 'price' is greater than K, then you know that the largest possible number must be lower than the middle number. So, narrow your search range to the lower half (from the lowest number to the middle number).
  7. Repeat steps 2 through 6, continually narrowing the search range, until you've found the largest possible number whose 'price' is within the limit K.

Code Implementation

def maximum_number(maximum_possible_number, maximum_sum_allowed):

    low_number = 0
    high_number = maximum_possible_number

    while low_number <= high_number:
        middle_number = (low_number + high_number) // 2
        price_of_middle_number = calculate_price(middle_number)

        # Check if middle number's price is within the allowed sum
        if price_of_middle_number <= maximum_sum_allowed:
            low_number = middle_number + 1

        # If price exceeds the limit, reduce the search range
        else:
            high_number = middle_number - 1

    return high_number

def calculate_price(number):
    # This function calculates price (e.g., count set bits)
    binary_representation = bin(number)[2:]
    price = binary_representation.count('1')
    return price

Big(O) Analysis

Time Complexity
O(log N) – The solution utilizes binary search to find the maximum number. Binary search repeatedly divides the search interval in half. In each step, it compares the middle element to the target value (K), and based on the comparison, eliminates half of the remaining search space. Since the search space is halved in each iteration, the time complexity is logarithmic with respect to the range of possible numbers (N), which in this case is the high end of the search space. Thus the time complexity is O(log N).
Space Complexity
O(1) – The binary search algorithm, as described, iteratively narrows down a range using a few constant space variables. We need variables to store the lower bound, upper bound, and middle point of the search range, along with the cost (or 'price') calculated for the middle number and the budget K. No auxiliary data structures like arrays, hash maps, or lists are created that scale with the input size (which implicitly dictates the search range). Thus, the space complexity is constant.

Edge Cases

k = 0
How to Handle:
Return 0 since a number with a digit sum of 0 is the only possible solution.
k is a very large number (e.g., close to the maximum integer value)
How to Handle:
The solution must handle potential integer overflow issues when constructing the large number; using strings is more robust.
k is a small positive number (e.g., 1, 2, 3)
How to Handle:
The solution should correctly return the largest single-digit number less than or equal to k.
k is greater than the maximum possible sum of digits for a number with the maximum number of digits allowed (e.g., all 9s)
How to Handle:
The solution should return a number comprised of nines until cost approaches k, and handle final value appropriately.
Resulting number has a very large number of digits exceeding integer representation limits
How to Handle:
Represent the resulting number as a string to avoid integer overflow problems.
k is negative
How to Handle:
Return an appropriate error message or potentially 0 as no positive number can have a negative digit sum.
Leading zeros are not allowed in the final number
How to Handle:
Ensure that the resulting number does not contain leading zeros unless the number is 0 itself.
Memory limits when k is extremely large
How to Handle:
Iteratively build the result string to minimize memory usage rather than allocating a large array.
0/1916 completed