Taro Logo

Reshape Data: Melt

Easy
Asked by:
Profile picture
34 views
Topics:
Arrays
DataFrame report
+-------------+--------+
| Column Name | Type   |
+-------------+--------+
| product     | object |
| quarter_1   | int    |
| quarter_2   | int    |
| quarter_3   | int    |
| quarter_4   | int    |
+-------------+--------+

Write a solution to reshape the data so that each row represents sales data for a product in a specific quarter.

The result format is in the following example.

Example 1:

Input:
+-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+-----------+
| product     | quarter_1 | quarter_2 | quarter_3 | quarter_4 |
+-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+-----------+
| Umbrella    | 417       | 224       | 379       | 611       |
| SleepingBag | 800       | 936       | 93        | 875       |
+-------------+-----------+-----------+-----------+-----------+
Output:
+-------------+-----------+-------+
| product     | quarter   | sales |
+-------------+-----------+-------+
| Umbrella    | quarter_1 | 417   |
| SleepingBag | quarter_1 | 800   |
| Umbrella    | quarter_2 | 224   |
| SleepingBag | quarter_2 | 936   |
| Umbrella    | quarter_3 | 379   |
| SleepingBag | quarter_3 | 93    |
| Umbrella    | quarter_4 | 611   |
| SleepingBag | quarter_4 | 875   |
+-------------+-----------+-------+
Explanation:
The DataFrame is reshaped from wide to long format. Each row represents the sales of a product in a quarter.

Solution


Clarifying Questions

When you get asked this question in a real-life environment, it will often be ambiguous (especially at FAANG). Make sure to ask these questions in that case:

  1. Can the `id_vars` and `value_vars` lists have overlapping column names, and if so, how should I handle that?
  2. What data types can the values within the dictionaries in `records` be (e.g., strings, numbers, booleans, nulls), and should I handle them differently?
  3. Is it possible for the `records` list to be empty, or for either `id_vars` or `value_vars` to be empty lists? What should I return in those cases?
  4. If a column name in `id_vars` or `value_vars` does not exist in the dictionaries within `records`, should I raise an error, skip the record, or handle it in another way?
  5. Is the order of the columns in `id_vars` important in the output, or can the output rows be in any order as long as they correctly represent the melted data?

Brute Force Solution

Approach

We're changing the shape of some information. The brute force method will try out absolutely every possible way to re-arrange and combine the initial data until we find the right shape. It's like trying every combination lock until one opens.

Here's how the algorithm would work step-by-step:

  1. Consider all the columns that you want to combine into a single, new column.
  2. For each row of the original data, go through each of those selected columns.
  3. For each original column in that row, create a new row where the new 'variable' column has the name of the original column, and the new 'value' column has the content of the original column.
  4. Repeat this for every row and every original column that you're trying to combine.
  5. The result is a long, skinny set of data where each row represents a single value that was previously in one of your original columns.

Code Implementation

def melt_data_brute_force(data, id_vars, value_vars): 
    melted_data = []

    # Iterate over each row in the original data
    for row in data:
        # Iterate through the columns to be melted
        for column_name in value_vars:

            # Create new row with variable and value
            new_row = {}
            for id_var in id_vars:
                new_row[id_var] = row[id_var]

            # Store the column name as the variable.
            new_row['variable'] = column_name

            # Get the value from the original column.
            new_row['value'] = row[column_name]

            melted_data.append(new_row)

    return melted_data

Big(O) Analysis

Time Complexity
O(n * m) – The brute force 'melt' operation iterates through each row of the original data which contributes a factor of n, where n is the number of rows. Inside the outer loop, it iterates through the selected columns that need to be combined, contributing a factor of m, where m is the number of columns to be melted. For each row and each selected column, a new row is created. Thus, the total number of operations is proportional to n multiplied by m. Therefore, the time complexity is O(n * m).
Space Complexity
O(N*M) – The algorithm iterates through each row of the original data and, for each row, iterates through a subset of the columns to be melted. In the worst case, we might need to melt almost all the columns for each row. For each such column, a new row is created in the reshaped data. Let N be the number of rows and M be the number of columns being melted. Therefore, in the worst-case scenario, we are creating N * M new rows, and the reshaped data will have N*M rows. Thus, the auxiliary space required to store the new data is proportional to N*M, resulting in a space complexity of O(N*M).

Optimal Solution

Approach

The goal is to transform data from a wide format to a long format. We'll selectively pick columns and 'unpivot' them into rows, repeating the identifying information as needed. This organized restructuring gives us a new representation of the data.

Here's how the algorithm would work step-by-step:

  1. First, identify the columns that will remain as identifiers (the 'id_vars'). These will be repeated across multiple rows.
  2. Next, select the columns that you want to melt, which are the ones to be transformed into rows (the 'value_vars').
  3. Create a new column called 'variable' which holds the original column names of the melted columns.
  4. Create another new column called 'value' that stores the values from the melted columns.
  5. For each row in the original data, create new rows for each melted column, copying the identifier columns and adding the 'variable' and 'value' from the melted column. Each melted column becomes a row.
  6. Combine all these new rows to produce the reshaped data. It's now in a long format, showing the original ID, the variable name, and its corresponding value.

Code Implementation

def melt_data(data, id_vars, value_vars):
    melted_data = []

    # Iterate over each row in the original data.
    for row in data:
        # Iterate over the columns to be melted.
        for column_to_melt in value_vars:
            # Create a new dictionary for each melted value.
            new_row = {}

            # Copy the identifier variables into the new row.
            for id_variable in id_vars:
                new_row[id_variable] = row[id_variable]

            # Add the variable name and value to the new row.
            new_row['variable'] = column_to_melt
            new_row['value'] = row[column_to_melt]

            # Append the new row to the melted data list.
            melted_data.append(new_row)

    return melted_data

def example_usage():
    data = [{
        'ID': 1, 'A': 10, 'B': 20, 'C': 30
    }, {
        'ID': 2, 'A': 40, 'B': 50, 'C': 60
    }]

    id_vars = ['ID']
    value_vars = ['A', 'B', 'C']

    melted_data = melt_data(data, id_vars, value_vars)
    print(melted_data)

if __name__ == '__main__':
    example_usage()

Big(O) Analysis

Time Complexity
O(n * m) – Let n be the number of rows in the original data and m be the number of columns that are melted (value_vars). For each of the n rows, the algorithm iterates through the m melted columns to create new rows. Inside the loop, the operations involve copying data which takes constant time. Therefore, the dominant cost is the nested process of iterating through rows and melted columns, resulting in a time complexity of O(n * m).
Space Complexity
O(M * N) – The algorithm creates a new dataset in long format. For each of the N rows in the original data, it creates M new rows, where M is the number of 'value_vars' columns being melted. Each of these new rows essentially stores copies of the 'id_vars' and the 'variable' and 'value' data, resulting in a new data structure to store the reshaped data of size proportional to M * N. Therefore, the auxiliary space complexity is O(M * N), where N is the number of rows in the original data and M is the number of columns being melted.

Edge Cases

records is null or empty
How to Handle:
Return an empty list immediately as there is no data to reshape.
id_vars is null or empty
How to Handle:
If no identifier variables are provided, the value variables should be melted, with each row potentially duplicated for each value variable.
value_vars is null or empty
How to Handle:
If no value variables are provided, return an empty list or the original list of records, depending on problem definition (clarify during interview).
id_vars and value_vars have overlapping column names
How to Handle:
This should be handled gracefully, likely giving precedence to id_vars or raising an exception, depending on the desired behavior (clarify during interview).
A column name in id_vars or value_vars does not exist in the records
How to Handle:
Raise an exception or skip the invalid column name, depending on desired behavior (clarify during interview).
Records have inconsistent schemas (different sets of columns)
How to Handle:
Handle the schema of the first record, and if others don't conform, either skip the row or raise an exception (clarify during interview).
Large number of records and/or value_vars, causing memory issues
How to Handle:
Ensure solution is memory-efficient and avoids creating large intermediate data structures, potentially using generators if the output is very large.
Data types of values in value_vars are mixed (e.g., string, int, null)
How to Handle:
The solution should handle various data types without errors and store them appropriately in the 'value' field, likely using a generic type or string conversion.