Taro Logo

Review stack rank undermines culture

Software Development Engineer In Test (SDET) II
Current Employee
Has worked at Microsoft for 6 years
November 8, 2012
Redmond, Washington
3.0
Positive OutlookNo CEO Opinion
Pros

Cutting-edge technology, smart peers, great pay, and benefits.

Great for a career in the industry.

Cons

The review system is a stack rank. This means that good employees must be put into the bottom rung... someone's got to be in the bottom rung. I always did well come review time, but the fact that it is run this way really undermines the collaboration and creativity that could exist at Microsoft. A very small number of folks are self-serving jerks who will step on folks to work this system. Everybody else is just unsure of who to trust and fearful of making mistakes that will be held against them. People play it safe or work crazy hours to offset the failure associated with prototyping.

Every talk I have with every manager I've ever had there is all about how I can 'get visibility'. It's not about how I can do a better job, or learn something new.

Advice to Management

Get rid of the stack rank!

Embrace a bit of failure as the price for innovation.

Was this helpful?

Microsoft Interview Experiences